‘Childless-by-circumstance: Is it different for men?’ by Robin Hadley

The grief, and stereotypes, that childless-by-circumstance women experience were movingly described by Jody Day on BBC Radio 4’s Woman’s Hour on the 1st of October, this year. During the programme, I tweeted that men are also childless-by-circumstance, and this was acknowledged by the host, who went on to suggest that, ‘The stereotypes don’t so easily attach themselves to men do they?’ Jody, to her credit, speculated that although men had a similar emotional journey as women it was a different one. The problem identified here relates to the heteronormative pronatalist view that ‘mothering’ and ‘nurturing’ are the ‘ideal’ default positions for women, while ‘virility’ and ‘providing’ are those for men. Women who do not conform, such as the voluntarily* and involuntarily* childless, are subject to a range of reactions from sympathy to antipathy. Moreover, the former tend to be viewed with less sympathy than the latter (Brescoll and Uhlman, 2005).

What then for men?

There is a paucity of research into male childlessness compared to the cannon of material on women (Throsby and Gill, 2004). Infertility studies report that men, diagnosed as infertile, are subject to negative behaviours, including: suspicion, exclusion, discrimination, and isolation, from both females and males, as are house-husbands and fathers who are widowers (Smith, 1998, Throsby and Gill, 2004, Hadley and Hanley, 2011). Men, who do not conform to fatherhood mandate – the patriarchal construct of ‘virility-proved-by-fertility‘ (Lloyd, 1996) – may behave in more extreme masculine ways or reduce their voice, and visibility, thus becoming ‘liminal’ (Hudson & Morgan, 2000; Ribbens & Edwards, 1998). Moreover, the male gender socialization is associated i.e. the ideal of hegemonic masculinity with symbolic roles of dominance, power, and control. These include masculine traits of machismo, virility, and objectivity and displayed through such behaviours as being emotionally distant, rational, and controlling. Wong and Rochlen’s (2005) study demonstrated that although men have the same emotional experience as women, their wherewithal to access, process, and verbalise their feelings were limited. In addition, research has indicated that childless men have a similar level of yearning for parenthood as childless women and, furthermore, childless men had higher levels of anger, depression, jealousy, and isolation than women (Hadley, 2009, 2012).

The distribution of stereotypes that the Woman’s Hour presenter alluded to reflected the dominant pronatalist positioning of women as nurturing/caring and men as aggressive/rational. As a researcher studying older childless-by-circumstance men, and as an involuntarily childless man who was very broody in his thirties (Hadley, 2013), challenging those stereotypes is not easy. Research in the field of older men who are involuntarily childless is important, not only because of actual and projected demographic change but also because of the lack of material reporting the effects of involuntary childlessness on men as they age (Dykstra and Keizer, 2009). For example, there are implications for the childless at national levels with much political rhetoric advancing the future centrality of family in the care of older relatives, with the demand for familial care in England projected to grow by about 90% by 2041 and exceed supply (Pickard et al., 2009). Gerontological research has shown that relationships and social support are as important as physical health for personal development and wellbeing. In Britain, there are a growing number of households of solo occupancy with an increasing number of older people living in that circumstance, the majority of whom are men. Childless people are clearly absent from policy discussions; for example, they are not referred to in the last Government’s strategy paper ‘Building a society for all ages’ (Department for Work and Pensions, 2009).

Robin Hadley is a PhD candidate at Keele University.

University profile: http://bit.ly/194quoN

Academia.edu profile: http://bit.ly/1a2JKAa

Research webpage: www.wantedtobeadad.com

Twitter: @robinhadley1
Email address:  r.a.hadley@keele.ac.uk

Postal address:
Claus Moser Building
Keele University, ST5 5BG,
United Kingdom

References:

Brescoll, V. L., & Uhlman, E. L. (2005). Attitudes toward traditional and non-traditional parents. Psychology of Women Quarterly, 29, 436–445.

Department for Work and Pensions. (2009). Building a society for all ages. Retrieved from http://www.hmg.gov.uk/media/33830/fullreport.pdf.

Dykstra, P. A. & Keizer, R. (2009). The wellbeing of childless men and fathers in mid-life. Ageing & Society, 29(8), 1227-1242.

Hadley, R. A. (2009). Navigating in an Uncharted World: How does the desire for fatherhood affect men? MSc Dissertation, The University of Manchester, Manchester

Hadley, R. A. (2012). Navigating in an Uncharted World: How does the desire for fatherhood affect men? Journal of Fertility Counselling, 19(01), 12-13.

Hadley, R. A. (2013). Robin Hadley: I know all about broody men who long to be dads. I am one. Telegraph Media Group.  http://www.telegraph.co.uk/men/relationships/fatherhood/9969542/Robin-Hadley-I-know-all-about-broody-men-who-long-to-be-dads.-I-am-one.html

Hadley, R. & Hanley, T. (2011). Involuntarily childless men and the desire for fatherhood.  Journal of Reproductive and Infant Psychology, 29(1), 56-68.

Hudson, B., & Morgan, D. (2000). Introduction: Making men into fathers. In B. Hudson (Ed.), Making men into fathers: Men, masculinities and the social politics of fatherhood (pp. 1–24). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Lloyd, M. (1996). Condemned to be meaningful: Non-response in studies of men and infertility. Sociology of Health & Illness, 18 (4), 433-454

Pickard, L., Wittenberg, R., King, D., Malley, J. & Comas-Herrera, A. (2009). Informal Care for Older People by their Adult Children: Projections of Supply and Demand to 2041 in England. London: The London School of Economics and Political Science. http://www.lse.ac.uk/collections/MAP2030/docs/InfCare_Pickardetal_2009.pdf

Ribbens, J., & Edwards, R. (1998). Public knowledge. In J. Ribbens & R. Edwards (Eds.), Feminist dilemmas in qualitative research: Public knowledge and private lives (pp. 1–23). London: SAGE.

Smith, C. D. (1998). “Men Donʼt do This Sort of Thing”: A Case Study of the Social Isolation of House Husbands. Men and Masculinities, 1 (2), 138–172

Throsby, K., & Gill, R. (2004). ‘It’s different for men’: Masculinity and IVF. Men and Masculinities, 6(4), 330–348.

Leave a Reply